• Sign Up! To view all forums and unlock additional cool features

    Welcome to the #1 Explorer ST Forum and Explorer ST community dedicated to Explorer ST owners and enthusiasts. Register for an account, it's free and it's easy, so don't hesitate to join the Explorer ST Forum today!


Real world mpg

Messages
408
Reactions
236
Points
37
Location
Ontario, Canada
#81
If mine is off, I believe it’s no more than 5% optimistic.
Even 5% off would mean your warranty would end fairly prematurely and likely impact resale values.
 

OP
l1tech

l1tech

Member
U.S. Army Veteran
Messages
118
Reactions
68
Points
27
Location
AZ
Vehicle
21 ST
Thread Starter #82
Hey, are you suggesting the vehicle odometer is of by 15%. That would be far more of a scandal than any of other complaints about the vehicle.
He is saying that the mpg calculation can be off as much as 15%. Typically vehicle odometers are extremely accurate unless you have drastically changed tire circumference and not corrected the vehicles computers.
 

st8

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,083
Reactions
481
Points
212
Location
Bel Air, MD, USA
#83
When I did my trip to Tennessee i started with 93, first fill up avg was around 24 with doing 75-80. Switched to 87 on my first fill up because 93 was nearly a full dollar more and wanted to see how 87 compared. From there averaged about the same 24-25. Stuck with 87 the rest of the trip. I had to do a lot of driving where I was so I just continued with 87.
 

Messages
318
Reactions
177
Points
37
Location
N. Florida
Vehicle
2020 ST
#84
Hey, are you suggesting the vehicle odometer is of by 15%. That would be far more of a scandal than any of other complaints about the vehicle.
No, federal law allows a 5% speedometer error. I don't recall if it's plus or minus or total and I don't know if odometers are held to a specific range. A long time ago, manufacturers had the odometer read a bit high, so if Joe Consumer traded when it got to 60,000, it may only have 57,200.

The odometer in my ST is 2.3% low. The speedometer is as dead-on as I could ever expect (< 1mph). That 15% error is the computer's guess about the MPG.
 

Cajun Heat

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,199
Reactions
597
Points
262
Location
Katy, TX, USA
Vehicle
2022 Explorer ST
#85
I've put a few 250+ mile highway trips on my ST (at 11k miles on the odometer) and can not get it above 22mpg at 75-80. I don't know how some of you are getting 24-26 mpg at that speed. Is it because I have a 2022 and some are driving older models?
 

hbalek

Active Member
Messages
978
Reactions
548
Points
232
Location
Kensington, MD, USA
#86
The more city driving you do, the more optimistic it is. The more highway driving the closer the estimate seems to be to reality. This has been my experience.
 

Last edited:
Messages
408
Reactions
236
Points
37
Location
Ontario, Canada
#87
No, federal law allows a 5% speedometer error. I don't recall if it's plus or minus or total and I don't know if odometers are held to a specific range. A long time ago, manufacturers had the odometer read a bit high, so if Joe Consumer traded when it got to 60,000, it may only have 57,200.

The odometer in my ST is 2.3% low. The speedometer is as dead-on as I could ever expect (< 1mph). That 15% error is the computer's guess about the MPG.
The odometer reading would be directly related to the speedometer reading, that would be how it calculated the distance travelled. Circumference of tires along with number of revolutions. Looking online it appears that thw 275/45ZR21s are about 3.4% smaller than the thw 255/55R20s. If Ford did not revise this in the ST that would account for some of the difference. I would assume that the measurement of fuel used would be suspect. After that calculating a MPG is pretty simple.
 

OP
l1tech

l1tech

Member
U.S. Army Veteran
Messages
118
Reactions
68
Points
27
Location
AZ
Vehicle
21 ST
Thread Starter #88
The odometer reading would be directly related to the speedometer reading,.
This is not correct. There are many mfgs that purposefully make the speedometer read faster than actual speed but the odometers are accurate. For example certain model BMW’S read 2 mph faster than actual speed but the odometers are accurate. I think they do this to avoid complaints about speeding tickets.
 

Messages
318
Reactions
177
Points
37
Location
N. Florida
Vehicle
2020 ST
#89
I don't think I've ever had a vehicle where the speedometer and odometer had the same error. My ST's speedometer is as accurate as could be expected, but the odometer is 2.3% low. I don't recall if I checked the Limited. The Escape needed 1.8% added to the odometer reading to get accurate distance covered. The Mustang is similar. Both speedometers are very close. My Ram was WAY off with 285/70x17s from 245/70x17s.
 

OP
l1tech

l1tech

Member
U.S. Army Veteran
Messages
118
Reactions
68
Points
27
Location
AZ
Vehicle
21 ST
Thread Starter #90
I don't think I've ever had a vehicle where the speedometer and odometer had the same error. My ST's speedometer is as accurate as could be expected, but the odometer is 2.3% low. I don't recall if I checked the Limited. The Escape needed 1.8% added to the odometer reading to get accurate distance covered. The Mustang is similar. Both speedometers are very close. My Ram was WAY off with 285/70x17s from 245/70x17s.
How are you verifying that your odometer is off? As far as the Ram goes of course it is going to be off after changing tire sizes.
 

Messages
318
Reactions
177
Points
37
Location
N. Florida
Vehicle
2020 ST
#91
I use my Garmin to test the odometer and speedometer.
 

OP
l1tech

l1tech

Member
U.S. Army Veteran
Messages
118
Reactions
68
Points
27
Location
AZ
Vehicle
21 ST
Thread Starter #92
I use my Garmin to test the odometer and speedometer.
I'm intrigued that you think that the Garmin is accurate and that the speedo/odo on the ST is wrong. At a difference of 2.3% it's not enough to worry about as the affect on mpg calculations would be minimal unless your hypermiling.
 

Messages
408
Reactions
236
Points
37
Location
Ontario, Canada
#93
I'm intrigued that you think that the Garmin is accurate and that the speedo/odo on the ST is wrong. At a difference of 2.3% it's not enough to worry about as the affect on mpg calculations would be minimal unless your hypermiling.
Straight and level, with good satellite coverage, should give you a fairly accurate speed. Outside of those conditions, gps information would be suspect in my experience. For measuring distances on highways we use a meter reader connected to the vehicle and is calibrated to suit the individual vehicle performance against a known (physically measured) highway section. Then s=d/t.
 

Messages
318
Reactions
177
Points
37
Location
N. Florida
Vehicle
2020 ST
#94
GPS is accurate to 10', the gadget checks in several times per minute. Why would I suspect it to be less accurate than the car? 2,600 miles of interstate qualifies as straight and level and good satellite coverage.
 

Messages
408
Reactions
236
Points
37
Location
Ontario, Canada
#95
GPS is accurate to 10', the gadget checks in several times per minute. Why would I suspect it to be less accurate than the car? 2,600 miles of interstate qualifies as straight and level and good satellite coverage.
Accurate to 10' is great for geochaching and finding you car after hiking, but not accurate at all for calculating the change in distance over a few seconds (I would think that your Garmin would sample more frequently than a few times a minute). At 60 mph your vehicle should move 88' per second and I would say if the GPS was out by 10' one direction for the first reading and then out by 10' the other direction for the second reading the total error could be 20' for what should be an 88' distance. That would be the extreme and likely it would average out, but the individual readings could be off by a large amount. I find my GPS to be close too, but it varies in readings as the vehicle maintains a constant speed by the spedometer. I have not noticed major discrepancies with my spedometer, that is why I am curious on this topic.
 

Messages
29
Reactions
18
Points
2
Location
Naples, FL, USA
#96
My mileage as calculated by the vehicle itself is usually between 23 and 25.

Long highway trips (VA to FL) we averaged 23.7 and was consistently around 80mph, summertime, and a rather full load of crap, 2 people and 2 little white fluffy girl dogs.

In town, which is a decent average mph of around 35-40mph (so not stop and go city driving), we get 23 every single time we fill up. We obviously drive very consistently and the same patterns.

We use 93 octane and drive normally, not crazy and not super slow either.

I have gotten 25.5 driving across Alligator Alley from Naples to Lauderdale in the "winter" and keeping it at the speed limit of 70 and actually trying to get the best mpg I could. That was literally all highway driving starting from the highway and ending on the highway.

2020 with 19,2xx miles on it and it is 2 years and 2 months old, bone stock.
 

st8

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,083
Reactions
481
Points
212
Location
Bel Air, MD, USA
#97
I've put a few 250+ mile highway trips on my ST (at 11k miles on the odometer) and can not get it above 22mpg at 75-80. I don't know how some of you are getting 24-26 mpg at that speed. Is it because I have a 2022 and some are driving older models?
Mine is a 22 and I was definitely hitting over 24 doing 75-80
 

Cajun Heat

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,199
Reactions
597
Points
262
Location
Katy, TX, USA
Vehicle
2022 Explorer ST
#98
Mine is a 22 and I was definitely hitting over 24 doing 75-80
:unsure:, guess mine just gets shittier fuel economy. Not going to sell it because of that, for now. I get rid of perfectly good cars all the time when my wife gets the itch for that new car smell.
 

st8

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,083
Reactions
481
Points
212
Location
Bel Air, MD, USA
#99
:unsure:, guess mine just gets shittier fuel economy. Not going to sell it because of that, for now. I get rid of perfectly good cars all the time when my wife gets the itch for that new car smell.
What’s your tire pressure? Yeah I wouldn’t sweat it. There’s a lot of other variables. Hills, weather, etc.
 

Cajun Heat

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,199
Reactions
597
Points
262
Location
Katy, TX, USA
Vehicle
2022 Explorer ST
What’s your tire pressure? Yeah I wouldn’t sweat it. There’s a lot of other variables. Hills, weather, etc.
Running 33psi. For sure, that's what I was thinking too.
 



Top