I'm late to this forum, but posting b/c someone else may research the same thing. I've had weathertech in multiple cars. I went with the Ford liners (for the front and 2nd row) this time and am really pleased with them. I like the softer rubber which covers the carpet and edges really well. Harder construction mats sometimes have a gap or hover over the edges a bit, these really rest in place very nicely. The rear mats extend over the middle hump too, which was a nice surprise since kids always step right on the middle section when getting in and out! These are thick rubber and seem very durable and easy to clean. The weathertech mats I've had before seemed to hold dirt in scratches and the texture. I was surprised at the quality of the Ford mats and pleased with the price ~$175