I ended up getting the Yokohamas and have put about a thousand miles on them so far, all types of driving. Here’s my overly critical review of them so far.
The Yokos feel much softer than the Pirellis so the overall ride comfort increased quite a bit, but it certainly feels less “sporty” with the slightly looser steering feel due to either the tall tread blocks, the increased sidewalk flex, or both. Felt like swapping out the summer tires for the Blizzaks - noticeably less responsive. I’ve been playing with pressures a bit because at the recommended 33psi they appeared kind of flat (just gets my anxiety ripping) and would pogo.
When really throwing it into a corner there’s a momentary lack of confidence until the tires set but once they do, these things really grip! We’ve had a record year for rain here in Minnesota as well so I’ve really been able to test their wet weather capabilities and they perform very well in this space. I’ve tried to get them to hydroplane around town and they won’t have it. I try to break them free under spirited driving, and you really have be in gas to get them to squirm.
Overall, I’m happy with the purchase.