• Sign Up! To view all forums and unlock additional cool features

    Welcome to the #1 Explorer ST Forum and Explorer ST community dedicated to Explorer ST owners and enthusiasts. Register for an account, it's free and it's easy, so don't hesitate to join the Explorer ST Forum today!


Interesting new find…and not a good one.

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
#1
Interesting find on the alignment rack today. I never saw it any time I was under the car but my buddy noticed it while he was setting the toe…the adjustment is maxed out and is actually bending the subframe. Notations on pics below. When it bends the subframe, it moves the tab the eccentric rides on outward which reduces the range of adjustment to get the toe “in”…this is an alignment killer. I don’t know the cause…I do drive this thing extremely hard on curvy roads so maybe that’s where the load is coming from? IMG_1606.jpeg

When you make an adjustment the eccentric rides on these tabs that are just punched in the thin subframe. All the tension/pressure is in this location.

IMG_1605.jpeg

Something is exerting enough force to cause the ends of the subframe to curl around onto the bushing. These bent spots should be straight. One side of the driver side was bent so far it was touching the toe link.

IMG_1604.jpeg

This is after a pry bar was used to bend it back straight.
 

Cruising68

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,620
Reactions
1,181
Points
262
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
#2
That is strange for sure. Not sure hot force could be applied to bend them like that. May be a candidate for welding a reinforcing plate. Curious what others have to say.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

TMac

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,706
Reactions
1,494
Points
262
Location
Knoxville, TN
#3
I would bet the bushing material is too soft. That's causing the mounting bolt to move which causes the eccentric to "ride up" over limit tab bending the ends of the mount.

Those are the aftermarkets from FenFab, right? They should have used a higher durometer bushing.
 

Cdubya

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,689
Reactions
841
Points
262
Location
NE Ohio
Vehicle
2020 Explorer ST
#4
I would bet the bushing material is too soft. That's causing the mounting bolt to move which causes the eccentric to "ride up" over limit tab bending the ends of the mount.

Those are the aftermarkets from FenFab, right? They should have used a higher durometer bushing.
The OEM part does not have those bushings sandwiched between there. Neither does the steeda part. they both have a bushing around a beefy steel collar which is what gets sandwiched. The Fen Fab design simply wont do for our particular application. You might replace the bushings with same thickness washers but why experiment?
 

OP
UNBROKEN

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Thread Starter #5
The OEM part does not have those bushings sandwiched between there. Neither does the steeda part. they both have a bushing around a beefy steel collar which is what gets sandwiched. The Fen Fab design simply wont do for our particular application. You might replace the bushings with same thickness washers but why experiment?
All poly bushings have a steel sleeve inside…including FenFab’s. It’s literally the only way they’ll work. The bushing style in Brett’s links is just like Steeda’s non-adjustable. IMG_1610.jpeg IMG_1612.jpeg
 

Last edited:

GearHead_1

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,555
Reactions
1,298
Points
262
Location
Utah
Vehicle
Exploder
#6
That's weird. I'd have to imagine that the bushing is softer than the OE. I'm sure all kinds of fixes are going through your head right now.

If it were me I'd probably look at pulling those links, straightening the sub-frame to the best of my ability (not easy, I know), essentially starting over. I wouldn't reuse those pieces as I suspect they're likely softer. I'd be tempted to try Steeda's adjustable toe links hoping the durometer rating of their bushing is stiffer. I have no idea but a few phone calls may reveal the specs of the bushings used in each application.

The picture of the Steeda parts looks like either the sleeve is super thick or it has a collar on it. It doesn't appear to have a large surface area for open bushing. With Steeda's you'd also get the benefit of more adjustment in setting the toe. Then I'd keep a very close eye on them to see if there is a repeat.

You could of course put your OE links back in assuming their length gives you the reach you need to set the toe. Short of replacing the sub-frame and starting over with OE parts, I'm not sure what else I could suggest.
 

GearHead_1

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,555
Reactions
1,298
Points
262
Location
Utah
Vehicle
Exploder
#7
The sleeve on Steeda's adjustable links looks different than the one in the fixed link pictured above. If the color is consistent throughout Steeda's line then their black bushing is stiffer than their red bushing. At least that is the way it was on their Differential Brace. As I said in the above post, I'm spitballing here.

Question here, is the bushing in between the link and the subframe on the FenFab link pictured above?

steeda-555-4118-v1-1__96821.jpg
 

Last edited:
OP
UNBROKEN

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Thread Starter #8
The sleeve on Steeda's adjustable links looks different than the one in the fixed link pictured above. If the color is consistent throughout Steeda's line then their black bushing is stiffer than their red bushing. At least that is the way it was on their Differential Brace. As I said in the above post, I'm spitballing here.

Question here, is the bushing in between the link and the subframe on the FenFab link pictured above?

View attachment 19976
Steeda posted a while back that their black bushing is harder than their red…most of the time. Sometimes they’re the same so we can’t go off color alone. At any rate…the FenFab bushing is 10X firmer than the oem. I made a video showing that when I got the links from Brett.
I agree on the wider footprint of the sleeve in the Steeda adjustable links. I think I’m gonna order a set tomorrow because even after straightening the bent spots on the frame it’s still maxed out on toe adjustment and I need some more.
 

GearHead_1

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,555
Reactions
1,298
Points
262
Location
Utah
Vehicle
Exploder
#9
I'm interested to see how this turns out. Best of luck.
 

88lx50

Member
Firefighter
Messages
26
Reactions
7
Points
2
Location
NYC
Vehicle
2023 Explorer ST
#10
I would bet the bushing material is too soft. That's causing the mounting bolt to move which causes the eccentric to "ride up" over limit tab bending the ends of the mount.

Those are the aftermarkets from FenFab, right? They should have used a higher durometer bushing.
It might be the opposite. The original was soft and made to flex. The polyurethane doesn’t flex and pulls the whole bolt and washer into that bumped part under tension, causing the ear to bend.
 

Cajun Heat

1000 Post Club
Messages
1,198
Reactions
597
Points
262
Location
Katy, TX, USA
Vehicle
2022 Explorer ST
#11
Watching. I just went out a looked at mine and they are still straight, although my FenFab links have not been on very long.
 

OP
UNBROKEN

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Thread Starter #12
Watching. I just went out a looked at mine and they are still straight, although my FenFab links have not been on very long.
I don’t think it has anything to do with the links.
I think it’s due to pulling hard AF on the eccentric to get the toe in more while everything was loose and the pressure tried to fold in the ends of the frame.
 

Messages
391
Reactions
360
Points
67
Location
Rancho Santa Margarita, CA, USA
Vehicle
2020 Explorer ST
#13
I don’t think it has anything to do with the links.
I think it’s due to pulling hard AF on the eccentric to get the toe in more while everything was loose and the pressure tried to fold in the ends of the frame.
This makes sense. I was looking at mine and trying to see how those ears could fold from driving, and the pivot points of everything don't seem to allow that much movement. It would need to be a large amount of fore/aft movement at the spindle to do that, and I'm sure something else would have broken or bent if that was the case. I understand these arms are transmitting more force to the joints than the cooked-spaghetti factory toe arms, but I just don't see where the movement could come from without leaving your rear suspension behind in the turn.

Are you going with the eccentric again or using the lock-out plate the Steeda includes? As for the durometer, like was said earlier, Steeda is usually consistent with red being softer and black being harder, but in the case of these arms, they told me the duromenter of the black bushing in the adjustable arms and the red bushing in the fixed-length arms is the same.
 

OP
UNBROKEN

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Thread Starter #14
I’m gonna lock them out and only use the arms adjuster. I’m confident that’ll fix this issue. They’re already ordered.
 

Messages
208
Reactions
81
Points
27
Location
Somalia
#15
is it possible the strengthened parts transmitted more force to parts that bent?
 

OP
UNBROKEN

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Thread Starter #16
I don’t believe so, no.
 

Polo08816

Member
U.S. Army Veteran
Law Enforcement
Messages
87
Reactions
35
Points
17
Location
Maryland
Vehicle
2014 BMW 335i
#17
Interesting find on the alignment rack today. I never saw it any time I was under the car but my buddy noticed it while he was setting the toe…the adjustment is maxed out and is actually bending the subframe. Notations on pics below. When it bends the subframe, it moves the tab the eccentric rides on outward which reduces the range of adjustment to get the toe “in”…this is an alignment killer. I don’t know the cause…I do drive this thing extremely hard on curvy roads so maybe that’s where the load is coming from? View attachment 19966

When you make an adjustment the eccentric rides on these tabs that are just punched in the thin subframe. All the tension/pressure is in this location.

View attachment 19968

Something is exerting enough force to cause the ends of the subframe to curl around onto the bushing. These bent spots should be straight. One side of the driver side was bent so far it was touching the toe link.

View attachment 19969

This is after a pry bar was used to bend it back straight.

Does anyone have a picture of the factory part to compare against this?
 

Messages
28
Reactions
6
Points
2
Location
Chattanooga, TN
Vehicle
2022 ST
#18
@UNBROKEN have you checked for anymore bending since installing the Steeda links?
 

OP
UNBROKEN

UNBROKEN

4000 Post Club
Messages
4,580
Reactions
5,355
Points
352
Location
Houston, TX, USA
Thread Starter #19
I have actually…just the other day. All is well.
 

Messages
28
Reactions
6
Points
2
Location
Chattanooga, TN
Vehicle
2022 ST
#20
I have actually…just the other day. All is well.
So do you really think it was the surface area of the bushing sleeve that made the difference? If anyone else has had the same issue using the Phenfab links I haven't seen it reported.
 



Top