Depends on where you live and your lifestyle... I'm a firm believer that if you have extreme winters and hot summers you need dedicated tires regardless of all-wheel drive. The tire compounds of all season tires don't give you the grip you need in extreme cold or extreme hot conditions, as compared to a set of winter tires for winter and summer tires for summer. I've swapped out wheels and tires every spring and again in the fall for too many years and cars to count. If all my travel was short distances on flat local roads that are well maintained without any family to consider... then I would probably be good with all-seasons. Especially during the winter in icy, hilly conditions you just can't beat a dedicated winter tire setup. I've had winters on a front wheel drive car and was in total control passing by others stuck on the side of the road because they thought they were invincible with all-wheel drive or 4wd... (not understanding that the tires make all the difference). Just my two cents